Spotting a Social Media Quack
Spotting a Social Media Quack
No Matter How Cute and Fuzzy
By D.S. Mitchell, author
Real or Not?
First, you can buy one of those white lab coats on the internet for as little as $10.00. Those wall certificates and awards forms, you know the blank ones you can fill in yourself can be purchased at Staples, Amazon, or Walmart for about $5.00 each. Those stethoscopes, a cheap one will be about $8.00. All I’m saying is, it’s easy to play a doctor on video. And sadly, folks get drawn in and don’t check on credentials but rely on emotion. “Isn’t he cute?” or “She sounds so smart.”
Trust or Mistrust?
So, here are a couple of things to watch for when viewing internet health videos or anything else for that matter. I’ve researched the internet (LOL) and there is an agreed group of telltale signs that you may be getting bad and/or dangerous information. The nice looking “doctor” we see in a YouTube video or hear about from an influencer who quotes studies and cite doctors, with the best of them, says is “great.” But seriously are these people we can trust? Well, the internet is the internet; where there is great truth, and at the same time probably greater fraud and fantasy. So, here are some tips on spotting quacks in lab coats.
- Using absolute statements: No product or person can give a 100% guarantee that a product or person will perform as described 100% of the time. That’s just reality. The “doctor or influencer” should allow for uncertainty in scientific research and performance. Science is constantly gathering new evidence and our knowledge evolves to a better and more complete understanding of the spotlighted issue or product.
- Non-experts: If a health coach is pushing hormones or “nutritional experts” who aren’t registered dietitians are making supplement replacement therapy recommendations, beware. Like anything when stepping outside their expertise their qualifications should be taken into consideration, in other words “take what they say with a grain of salt” as my mom used to say.
- Avoid mavericks: Be suspicious of people who claim they are the outlaws, the rebels, the mavericks, going against the grain of the scientific consensus. There is a study for everything with diverse results; however what does the overall research show. Going against the grain is great, I love the curious and questioning mind, however if 20 people reported terrible pain during a procedure, while 3 respondents reported relatively little pain. I would take the word of the 20 over the 3. So that’s how I feel about those 3 mavericks.
- They are selling something: I think, ‘caution’ when watching a video in which the presenter is focused on selling their chosen product is wise advice. I of course, buy a wide variety of crap off the internet and for the most part have been satisfied, all I’m saying is check on any of their claims and subject matter expertise before you decide to purchase. Or, if you wanna give it a try and you are dissatisfied post purchase you have multiple refund resources. First the company you bought it from, then your bank’s fraud department if the company refuses to give you your money back. Most likely if you have a valid claim you will get your refund.
